“Rethinking ADHD” Misses the Mark: A Clinician’s Response to the NYT Article by Paul Tough

ADHD

“Rethinking ADHD” Misses the Mark: A Clinician’s Response to the NYT Article by Paul Tough

AcademicAlly, LLC: April 22, 2025

H
Hannah Bookbinder
••7 min read
“Rethinking ADHD” Misses the Mark: A Clinician’s  Response to the NYT Article by Paul Tough

AcademicAlly, LLC: April 22, 2025

Individuals who live with ADHD face daily challenges related to their neurodivergence:time blindness, disorganization, lack of personal accountability, impulsivity, etc.Unfortunately, the symptoms they encounter are nearly the tip of the iceberg as thisdemographic is (and has been) encountering policy challenges that call into questionthe validity of this neurodevelopmental disorder along with access to treatment, loss ofschool and work accommodations, and a decrease in insurance coverage. One cannotoverlook the dramatic shortage of available medication, a lifeline for so many who haveADHD. Stimulants medications have become harder and harder to come by, leavingmany without appropriate dosages, leaving them susceptible to engagement inchallenging and potentially dangerous situations.

What further complicates the situation is inaccurate journalistic coverage of thisdisorder. In a recent New York Times Magazine article, entitled “Have We BeenThinking About ADHD All Wrong?”, writer Paul Tough proposes that ADHD and how ithas been diagnosed and treated is not effective or beneficial. While it is always helpfulto re-evaluate how any medical, neurodevelopmental, or psychological diagnosis isevaluated and treated, if the mechanism by which one is distributing such information isseriously (and potentially dangerously) inaccurate, such a piece does more harm thangood. As many well-known professionals who are well-versed in the field and study ofADHD took to the airwaves to comment on this article, including Russell Barkley, I feltvalidated in my opinion of Tough’s report: it undermined the many decades of researchdedicated to the study of this disorder as well as the very real experiences of those wholive with it.

In a four-part commentary on his YouTube channel, Barkley lays out the facts andwhere Tough got it so very wrong:ADHD is Not and Arbitrary Diagnosis: Tough indicates that loose guidelines are used todiagnose this disorder as there is “no single biological marker” to indicate its existence.Barkley states that similar to most psychiatric disorders, ADHD is diagnosed using “standardized, evidence-based clinical criteria” (as found in the DSM-5). These arecorroborated by behavior rating scales, interviews with the individuals themselves aswell as their family members and (in the case of school-aged children) teachers, anddevelopmental histories. This assessment process is far from the willy-nilly approachTough suggests in his writing.

Barkley goes on to discuss the MTA (Multimodal Treatment of Attention DeficitHyperactivity Disorder) Study conducted by Joseph Swanson. This study was used tosupport the idea that the benefits of utilizing medication are short-lived. In reality, theMTA study initially found that the most effective course of treatment was to combinemedication and behavioral therapy. However, a flaw of the MTA study was its design:participants were broken into four core groups-placebo (no treatment at all), behavioralintervention, medication, and a combination of behavior and medication. Over thecourse of 14 months, these groups received (or didn’t in the case of the placebo group)their treatment. At the end of 14 months, the participants had the freedom to discontinuetheir treatment or change the treatment they wished to utilize. The study went on forfour years, so as time passed beyond the 14 months, the results were “muddied”because participants weren’t required to adhere to any strict protocols for treatment. AsBarkley points out, “inconsistent use doesn’t mean the treatment doesn’t work.The next point that must be addressed is Tough’s assertion that medication is ineffectiveand addictive. After one to two years of use, patients frequently stop using theirmedication to address their symptoms. If the medication in question is truly addictive,then people would not be able to abandon them so quickly. As to the notion of efficacy,Barkley states that the proper treatment of ADHD with stimulants actually lowers the riskof substance abuse by addressing some of the core issues people living with ADHDstruggle with including impulsivity, anxiety, and depression, all of which can lead to self-medication.

As to the dramatic rise in rates of ADHD diagnoses, Tough suggests this is reflective ofa social trend, stating that “these [diagnoses] are to some extent arbitrary” is adangerous and misguided assertion-see my comment earlier about the regimentedscreening process that guide clinicians’ evaluations of their patient. Rates of diagnoseshave definitely increased (according to Barkley and other reputable sources rates areup from 3% in the 1980’s to today’s rate of 5-7%) but for good and clinically-substantiated reasons. Researchers now know how to more effectively recognize ADHDacross age, gender, and racial lines. Adults, who were not successfully evaluated (if atall) as children have now received proper diagnosis and intervention. Historically,because women and girls tend to demonstrate the distracted symptoms of ADHD, theygo undiagnosed. They are not engaged in the stereotypical disruptive behavior thatmany associate with ADHD. This is not overdiagnosis, as Barkley rightfully points out; it is equity. The people who have this disorder are finally receiving the attention and carethey need to function effectively in their daily lives.

Any responsible writer needs to ensure his sources are current and accurate. Toughuses outdated research to support his assertions. For example, he cites a studyconducted by Hinshew and Lambert which is over twenty years old, and fails toincorporate current research, denying readers the chance to view the current researchlandscape of ADHD. Swanson’s work, upon which Tough relies heavily, is “cherry-picked” from the older phases of the researcher’s work, failing to acknowledge abroader consensus of other researchers or more current data. Equally as important isBarkley’s recognition of the fact that Tough did not actually interview any of theresearchers whose studies he cites in his article. This leaves a lot of room formisinformation and little opportunity to delve more deeply into the topic, which wouldhave afforded Tough the opportunity to check his facts and more accurately report onADHD.

What I find so troubling about this article is the fact that it has the potential to causesignificant harm to the individuals who live with ADHD as well as their families. Theycast doubt about possible courses of treatment- most professionals like myself andBarkley endorse the most effective treatment plan is four-fold: once the diagnosis ismade, the individual and their family members need to be educated about the disorder,how it can impact daily living, and treatment options; medication may or may not beappropriate, depending on the individual’s age and how the person is presenting(regardless, it should be discussed, including the benefits and risks associated withtaking it); behavioral interventions by way of cognitive therapy or (preferably) coachingneed to be included in the treatment plan; and finally, accommodations in the places theindividual spends most of their time (ie work, home and school) must be discussed andimplemented.

Articles like Tough’s can prevent individuals from seeking and receiving the care theyneed. This can lead to dangerous decisions related to impulsivity including drinking anddriving, inappropriate texting, and self-medication with alcohol and illicit drugs, amongother troubling behaviors. Without proper care, individuals with ADHD are destined tosuffer.

Tough’s article was misleading, and the takeaway is not that professionals andresearchers like me are getting ADHD wrong, rather that he and the New York TimesMagazine got it wrong about ADHD.

ADHD is real. It is not limited to one arena of an individual’s life; it affects every facet ofthe human experience. As such, it must be addressed and respected as we do anyother “legitimized” diagnosis. As Barkley rightfully points out, “science, not speculation,must lead the conversation.” It is critical that any reporting that is written about this neurodevelopmental disorder is accurate so that people who live with ADHD and thegreater society are properly informed.

Explore Topics

#ADHD#organization#anxiety#study skills
H

Written by

Hannah Bookbinder

Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.

Related posts